Tuesday, November 16, 2010

yay or nay: ponchos

Next up on 'Yay or Nay' - Ponchos.
What's old is new again....
What do you think? Too trendy? Warm and cozy? The perfect coat?
I'm undecided... but I think I'm leaning towards Yay. I need you to convince me one way or another!

{Dakota is always adorable... poncho or no poncho}

{liking the pattern; I'm thinking Kim pulls it off yes?}

{styling not right but again, liking the pattern}

{just meh...bad color, shape, and picture}

Can't wait to hear - yay or nay?
xoxo


17 comments:

Ian said...

No, nay, never. They just aren't sexy.

stylebyrachael said...

Yay all the way! But ladies, please wear the right color for your skin and hair. You don't want to get washed out like both Dakota and Jessica!

Lindsay said...

I don't know if I would wear this out, but it would be perfect for lounging around or traveling on an airplane.

Collins said...

Yay for you but not me. You could totally pull it off!

Sarah Ann said...

I agree with each of your little captions. Jessica Simpson's is especially gross, but it is possible to pull it off!

Chassity (Look Linger Love) said...

Yay Yay Yay!

Jen said...

I think I'm with you, hanging out on that fence...

Leslie said...

I say YAY! I was a fan a couple years ago when they came out and still a fan. Maybe being preggo has something else to do with it, but they seem extra cozy! I'm actually picking up one my mom has this weekend that she knitted when she was preggo 35 years ago, and I LOVE IT!!

Summer {Bisfor...} said...

on the fence over here too. i have one but not sure. eeek.

Holly said...

i think they'd swallow me up. its a commitment i think. id wanna take it off after a half hour im thinking, haha

bananas. said...

i'm neither yay or nay...can i be may, as in mayyybe? lol.

Mommy Lisa said...

I have TWO Ralph Lauren wool/cashmere blend ponchos I have been wearing for YEARS. They are the perfect winter coat.

Danna and Kirk said...

I am undecided too, not sure what to think. I think it can be a very cute look when done right.

besswess said...

Anything on Kim is fantastic. I think it would have to be the right situation. I might adopt this style choice.

drollgirl said...

i know some people don't like them, but they look pretty cute to me as long as the pattern and/or color isn't balls-out bonkers! and maybe not wearing it every day, but every once in a while is sure cute!

Jo said...

I'm a yay!! And, I agree with you on all four. I do think, though, that the one on Jessica Simpson might look better on someone with different coloring (a red head or a brunette). It's cute, but the color just blends in too much with her skin and hair.

Eva said...

I do think they're pretty cute!